MERIP
Middle East Report
Middle East Report Online
Newspaper Op-Eds
Contact Info
Subscribe
Back Issues
Internships
Giving
Search
Subscribe Online to
Middle East Report

Order a subscription and back issues to the award-winning magazine Middle East Report.

Click here for the order page.

SPECIAL PUBLICATIONS

Report of the Task Force for a Responsible Withdrawal from Iraq June 2008 [Click to view PDF]

Primer on Palestine, Israel and the Arab-Israeli Conflict
Click here (PDF)

[Click here for HTML version]

 

 

 
MER 212 Table of Contents

Economics of Palestinian Return Migration

Ward Sayre and Jennifer Olmsted

Palestinians living in the West Bank and Gaza have faced a series of economic shocks since the Gulf War. Each shock alone would have been difficult to weather, but combined they have led to a considerable worsening of economic conditions. These shocks included the Gulf War, Israeli closures of the West Bank and Gaza and the influx of diaspora Palestinians after the Oslo Accords. While the first two clearly had negative consequences, the last is more complex. The repatriation of diaspora Palestinians has led to a reversal of the "brain drain," and an influx of much needed capital. Yet the impact of this spending has been disappointing and widening economic inequality may have resulted.

The Gulf War and Closure

The Gulf War reduced to a trickle Palestinians' access to better-paying employment opportunities outside the West Bank and Gaza. This curtailing of migration options coincided with one of most extensive closures ever imposed by Israel on the territories. During the Gulf War Israeli closures of the West Bank and Gaza led to economic losses averaging $1.8 million in wages and $850,000 in exports per day, according to World Bank estimates.1 Immediately after the war, the number of Palestinian workers allowed to work in Israel returned to pre-war levels. However, closures continued and employment opportunities in Israel have steadily declined. Whereas before the Gulf war 30 to 40 per cent of the Palestinian labor force was employed inside Israel, UNSCO estimates suggest that by 1998 that figure dropped to 17 percent. 2

Those directly affected by the closure were primarily young men who had been employed in Israel's construction, service and agricultural sectors. In addition, entrepreneurs and self-employed contractors who conducted business inside Israel were prohibited from pursuing those options after closure. The simultaneous expulsion of Palestinians from the Gulf, many of whom were unable to repatriate their savings and capital, exacerbated the impact on local labor markets. In 1991-2 for instance, districts with higher return migration, such as Khalil (Hebron), North Gaza Strip and Tulkarem saw their unemployment rates increase by 2 percent more than districts like Ramallah and Bethlehem where return migration was decreasing.3 Although those directly impacted were unemployed workers, the entire economy deteriorated as a result of this economic strain. Fewer jobs and lower earnings led to less consumption, in turn affecting local businesses and industries as the demand for their products declined. As a result, per capita GDP (average income per person) dropped by about 14.2 percent between 1993 and 1995.4 In addition, future migration possibilities were largely curtailed.

Aftermath of the Oslo Accords

With the economy reeling from the dual shocks of the Gulf War and the closures, the Oslo Accords brought about a new influx of diaspora Palestinians.5 This third shock has had both positive and negative features. From a nationalistic perspective, repatriating Palestinians is an exciting and positive step. In addition, returnee capital may be key to jumpstarting the Palestinian economy. How has the influx of returnees affected the West Bank and Gaza?

Estimates of the number of post-Oslo returnees range from 40,000 to 100,000.6 The two most prominent groups of "returnees"7 are the "Tunisians" and the Palestinian-Americans. In Gaza, many of the returnees are "Tunisians": PLO officials formerly based in Tunisia, allowed into the territories to staff the Palestinian National Authority (PNA). In the West Bank, many of the post-1993 returnees come from the United States. Unlike those who returned legally under the provisions of the Declaration of Principles, many of the Palestinian-Americans lost their residency rights while abroad and were able to come back only by skirting Israeli laws. These returnees often have foreign passports and enter with tourist visas or with family reunification papers. While not officially repatriated, many Palestinian-Americans are attempting to re-integrate into Palestinian society and the economy by building houses and investing in businesses, particularly in the restaurant and tourist industry.

The impact of the Post-Oslo returnees on the labor market has been less severe than earlier repatriations, since most have moved into newly created public sector positions in administration, security, etc. 12,000 positions in the Palestinian police force, for instance, went to "returnees."8 In addition, many returnees were successful in their businesses and professions in the diaspora and have come with ample amounts of capital and skills that could be vital in improving the Palestinian economy. Recently repatriated Palestinians have strong links with other Palestinians in the diaspora, as well as to the global economy. For example, investment groups such as the Palestine Development and Investment Company, Ltd. (PADICO), funded by local and diaspora capital, seek to generate employment not only in the service and construction sectors, but also in light manufacturing and infrastructure development. Economic theory suggests that such investments, especially in infrastructure (including transportation, communications, etc.) are vital to employment creation and sustained economic growth.

The repatriation of many economically successful entrepreneurs and educated Palestinians suggests a reversal of the "brain drain," and may bring in money earned abroad, which can stimulate the economy. But the type of returnee investment is an important consideration. UNSCO reports that 80 percent of "investment" in the region is in construction of private dwellings, 9 which provides jobs in the short run, but is not a solid basis for long-term economic growth. In addition, despite inflows of returnee spending, not to mention foreign aid, reports indicate that unemployment rates have remained high, averaging from 20 to 30 percent in 1997.10

Social and Political Repercussions

While the repatriated Palestinians may provide an economic boost to the territories, the benefits have been unevenly distributed. Tension between returnees and locals has emerged, particularly as returnees are generally better off economically. The corruption scandal that has plagued the Palestinian Authority for the past year alleges that $326 million in public funds were squandered in 1996.11 People also resent the special privileges, like VIP passes to go between the West Bank and Gaza Strip, that are given to returnees, while local workers are not being allowed to get to their jobs in Israel. Many of the charges of corruption and indifference to the suffering of the Palestinian people have been directed against the Tunisians, especially in Gaza. As foreign aid flowed toward non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and the PNA, governmental and non-governmental employees used their salaries to enjoy the new discos and restaurants that were built with returnee investment money. This extravagance has bred resentment among non-returnee Palestinians, many of whom have seen their standard of living decline. Returnees have been accused of using legal loopholes that they helped create in the economic accords in order to profit personally from Palestinian "autonomy." While not all returnees are corrupt and amoral, such perceived differences between locals and returnees help fuel political opposition to the PNA. Without investments that emphasize longer term economic growth the initial benefits brought by returnees may dissipate, while the increased economic disparities between the haves and have-nots may further inflame political tensions.

 

Endnotes

1 International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, Developing The Occupied Territories: An Investment in Peace, Vol. 2, The Economy (Washington, DC: The World Bank, Sept. 1993), p. 10.

2 United Nations Special Coordinator in the Occupied Territories (UNSCO), UNSCO Report on Economic and Social Conditions in the West Bank and Gaza (Jerusalem: UNSCO, Spring 1998), http://www.arts.mcgill.ca/mepp/unsco/unfront.html.

3 These calculations are by the authors using the Territories Labor Force Survey data collected by the Israeli Central Bureau of Statistics.

4 Radwaan Shaban, "Living Standards in the West Bank and Gaza Strip," working paper, MAS Study Paper No. 14-0017 (Ramallah: Economic Monitoring Unit of the Palestine Economic Policy Research Institute (MAS) August, 1997) reports per capita GDP of $883 and $1551 in 1995 for Gaza and the West Bank, a decline of 8.4 and 19.7 per cent respectively during this period, http://www.palecon.org/masdir/publications/livingstandards.html

5 For an economic critique of the Oslo accords, see Jennifer Olmsted, "Thwarting Palestinian Development," Middle East Report 201 (October-December, 1996), pp. 11-13.

6 Michele Chabin, "An Uneasy Homecoming" (Jerusalem Post, July 21, 1998, p. 11), states that official estimates of legal returnees range from 40,000 to 50,000, with unofficially repatriated returnees estimated at no more than 50,000. Abbas Shiblak of the Palestinian Diaspora and Refugee Centre (Shaml) reports an estimate of 60,000 in the preface to Reintegration of the Palestinian Returnees, Monograph #6, (Bethlehem: Shaml Publication, 1997). In the same publication, a discussion paper by Jill Tansley titled "Adaptation in the West Bank and Gaza Strip" cites a figure of 52,000 as of 1997. For Tansley and Shiblak see http://www.shaml.org/publications/mono6.htm.

7 The use of the term "returnee" is somewhat problematic, since some of these Palestinians never did live in Palestine, having been born in the Diaspora. Still, the terms "returnee" and "local" will be used to identify those who have recently "returned" based on the Oslo accords from those who have been residents in the West Bank and Gaza Strip for a longer period of time.

8 "Adaptation in the West Bank and Gaza Strip," op. cit.

9 UNSCO Report on Economic and Social Conditions in the West Bank and Gaza, op. cit.

10 Ibid. These estimates do not include the underemployed, i.e. people who work less hours than they would like.

11 Palestinians Souring on Arafat's Leadership," (Toronto Star, April 27, 1999).

Back to MER 212 Table of Contents

 

 

 

DonateNow

Search MERIP

MERIP OP-EDS
Rebranding the Iraq War
 Antiwar.com
 August 24, 2010
Chris Toensing

The war in Iraq is over. Or so the government and most media outlets will claim on Sept. 1, by which time thousands of U.S. troops will have departed the land of two rivers for other assignments. With this phase of the drawdown, says President Barack Obama, “America’s combat mission will end.” The Pentagon is marking the occasion by changing the name of the Iraq deployment from Operation Iraqi Freedom to Operation New Dawn. Full Story>>

Ethno-Sectarian Approach Likely to Have Lasting Consequences
 Bitter Lemons International
 July 22, 2010
Chris Toensing

Which American has done the most harm to Iraq in the twenty-first century? The competition is stiff, with George W. Bush, Dick Cheney, Paul Wolfowitz and L. Paul Bremer, among others, to choose from. But, given his game efforts to grab the spotlight, it seems churlish not to state the case for Vice President Joe Biden. Full Story>>

It's Time for Israel to End the Gaza Siege
 The Wayne Independent (Honesdale, PA)
 June 29, 2010
Bayann Hamid

Why would the Israeli navy commandeer boats carrying collapsible wheelchairs and bags of cement to the Gaza Strip? Israel says that the aid convoys are trying to "break the blockade" of the densely populated Palestinian enclave. But why is there a blockade in the first place? Full Story>>

Sects and the City
 New York Times Magazine
May 17, 2010
Moustafa Bayoumi

I had almost forgotten I’d sent in an application when the e-mail message appeared, like Mr. Big, out of nowhere. “Hi, Moustafa,” it began, as if we were old friends. “Thank you for e-mailing us regarding your interest in working on ‘Sex and the City 2.’ ”

No way. Last August, I half-jokingly answered an e-mail message posted on a list-serv requesting “lots of Middle Eastern men and women” as extras for the second “Sex and the City” movie (opening this week). Although I must have been one of the very few in the tri-state area to possess all the talents requested in the e-mail (legal to work, Middle Eastern and between 18 and 70 years old), I still never thought I would be selected. Two months later, I got the call. Full Story>>

A Web Smaller Than a Divide
 The New York Times
 May 14, 2010
Sinan Antoon

At first glance, there’s a clear need for expanding the Web beyond the Latin alphabet, including in the Arabic-speaking world. According to the Madar Research Group, about 56 million Arabs, or 17 percent of the Arab world, use the Internet, and those numbers are expected to grow 50 percent over the next three years. Many think that an Arabic-alphabet Web will bring millions online, helping to bridge the socio-economic divides that pervade the region. But such hopes are overblown. Full Story>>

A New Conversation Peace
The National (Abu Dhabi)
April 9, 2019
 Chris Toensing

Iyad Allawi, the not terribly popular interim premier of post-Saddam Iraq, is in a position to form a government again because he won over the Sunni Arabs residing north and west of Baghdad in the March 7 elections. The vote, while it did not “shove political sectarianism in Iraq toward the grave,” as Allawi would have it, rekindled the hopes of many that “nationalist” sentiment has asserted itself over communal loyalty. Full Story>>

Arming Yemen Against Al-Qaeda
 The Register Citizen (Torrington, CT)
 January 21, 2010
Sheila Carapico

Americans got a crash course on Yemen for Christmas.

That’s because we’ve wanted to know more about the little-known, dirt-poor country in southwestern Arabia where the “underwear bomber” who tried to blow up a plane—bound for Detroit from Nigeria on Christmas Day—says he was trained. President Barack Obama says, correctly, that “large chunks” of Yemen “are not fully under government control.” So it seems to make sense to strengthen the Yemeni government, to get at “al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula,” as the local gang of Islamist extremists is known. Full Story>>

Christmas is Bittersweet in Bethlehem
 The Milford Daily News (Milford, MA)
 December 24, 2009
George Rishmawi

Bethlehem, Palestine is a special place to celebrate Christmas. It’s home to the Church of the Nativity and the field where shepherds, tending their flocks by night, spotted the star heralding Jesus’ birth. But apart from the historical mystique, here in Bethlehem we celebrate Christmas much like Christians throughout the world. We hang lights from the rooftops. We erect a tree in Manger Square. We host a Christmas market. Our children carol and perform Christmas pageants. Christmas in Bethlehem, as elsewhere, is a time for family, peace, love and joy. Full Story>>

More Troops Won't Do It
 The Herald (New Britain, CT)
 November 13, 2009
Chris Toensing

For the past two months, President Barack Obama has been weighing Gen. Stanley McChrystal’s request to send an additional 40,000 troops to Afghanistan to “disrupt, dismantle and defeat” al-Qaeda. That same effort, according to Obama, entails ensuring that the Taliban can’t regain control of the country. But a military strategy alone won’t beat al-Qaeda or the Taliban. Achieving lasting stability in Afghanistan will require national political reconciliation, the establishment of a functioning, accountable political system, and a credible government. In this respect, the outcome of Afghanistan’s presidential election, marred by cheating, was a step in the wrong direction. Full story>>

Fort Hood Shootings: Again We Will Be Judged for Acts We Didn't Commit
 The Guardian
 November 6, 2009
Moustafa Bayoumi

So much is still unknown about the shooting at Fort Hood Army base and the motives of the alleged shooter, Nidal Malik Hasan, but still I have that same queasy feeling in my stomach that I've had before: this will not be good for Muslims. Full Story>>

Western Sahara Poser for UN
 Reuters (Africa Blog)
 April 28, 2009
Jacob Mundy

Morocco serves as the backdrop for such Hollywood blockbusters as Gladiator, Black Hawk Down and Body of Lies. The country’s breathtaking landscapes and gritty urban neighbourhoods are the perfect setting for Hollywood’s imagination.

Unbeknown to most filmgoers, however, is that Morocco is embroiled in one of Africa’s oldest conflicts - the dispute over Western Sahara. This month the UN Security Council is expected to take up the dispute once more, providing US President Barack Obama with an opportunity to assert genuine leadership in resolving this conflict. But there’s no sign that the new administration is paying adequate attention. Full Story>>

Letters, He Gets Letters
 Bitter Lemons International
March 26, 2009
Chris Toensing

Shortly before assuming office, President Barack Obama was handed a missive signed by such Washington luminaries as ex-national security advisers Zbigniew Brezezinski and Brent Scowcroft, urging him to “explore the possibility” of direct contact with Hamas. One month after he entered the White House, Obama received an epistle from Ahmad Yousef, a Gaza-based spokesman for the Islamist movement, making the same recommendation. “There can be no peace without Hamas,” Yousef told the New York Times when asked about the letter's contents. “We congratulated Mr. Obama on his presidency and reminded him that he should live up to his promise to bring real change to the region.”

There is no word, as yet, on how the foreign policy doyens' message was received, but Yousef's occasioned a huffy US rebuke of the UN Relief Works Agency, whose top official in Gaza, Karen Abu Zayd, passed the letter to Sen. John Kerry while he was visiting the devastated territory in mid-February. Even a single sealed envelope, it seems, creates the appearance that the Obama administration is breaking with the US vow, enunciated first under President George W. Bush, not to speak with Hamas until it agrees to renounce violence, abide by previous Palestinian agreements with Israel and recognize Israel as a Jewish state. Full Story>>

Elections Are Key to Darfur Crisis
 The Montreal Gazette
March 7, 2009
Khalid Medani

It has been quite a week. For the first time, the international community indicted a sitting president of a sovereign state. Omar al-Bashir of Sudan stands accused by the International Criminal Court in The Hague of "crimes against humanity and war crimes" committed in the course of the Khartoum regime's brutal suppression of the revolt in the country's far western province of Darfur. Having indicted two other figures associated with the regime in 2007, ICC prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo began building a case against the man at the top, and on Wednesday, the court issued a warrant for Bashir's arrest. Full Story>>

Out of the Rubble
The National
January 23, 2009
Mouin Rabbani

Speaking to his people on January 18, hours after Hamas responded to Israel’s unilateral suspension of hostilities with a conditional ceasefire of its own, the deposed Palestinian Authority prime minister Ismail Haniyeh devoted several passages of his prepared text to the subject of Palestinian national reconciliation. For perhaps the first time since Hamas’s June 2007 seizure of power in the Gaza Strip, an Islamist leader broached the topic of healing the Palestinian divide without mentioning Mahmoud Abbas by name.

At a press conference the following day convened by Abu Ubaida, the spokesperson of the Martyr Izz al Din al Qassam Brigades, the Hamas military wing, the movement went one step further. “The Resistance”, Abu Ubaida intoned, “is the legitimate representative of the Palestinian people”. Full Story>>

The Horrors of Israel's Peace
Al Ahram Weekly
January 22-28, 2009
Samera Esmeir

Three weeks after the war on Gaza, Israel declared a unilateral ceasefire but refused to terminate its so-called defensive operations. In response, Hamas declared a ceasefire for one week, until the withdrawal of Israeli troops has been completed. For many in the West, the ceasefire might seem like an occasion to celebrate, for the cessation of military hostilities on both sides will perhaps renew the peace process. But there are reasons to be critical of this ceasefire, since it continues the situation in which Israel acts unilaterally. What we are actually witnessing is a new phase of the catastrophe in Gaza. While the characteristics of this phase are not yet known, Israel's violence has become ever more evident. And perhaps this is why Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert did not mention the word "peace" once in the speech he gave to announce the ceasefire. The "peace process" might soon be revealed as the other side of the coin to war -- its continuation by other means -- that simultaneously feeds it. Full Story>>

A Battleground for the Foreseeable Future
Bitter Lemons International
September 11, 2008
Chris Toensing

Bob Woodward’s four books chronicling the wars of President George W. Bush are sensitive barometers of conventional wisdom in Washington. Whereas the first volume, published in 2002 at the height of the self-righteous nationalism gripping the capital after the September 11, 2001 attacks, hailed Bush’s self-confidence in acting to protect the homeland, the 2008 installment depicts the same man as cocksure and incurious. This much is not news. More educational are Woodward’s hints about the worldviews that will outlast this unpopular administration, embedded in the organs of the national security state. Full Story>>

Egypt Stifles Debate in the United States
 Northwest Arkansas Times
 August 27, 2008
Bayann Hamid

The Egyptian regime has once again succeeded in stifling freedom of speech, this time not in Egypt, but in the US. Earlier this month, an Egyptian court convicted a prominent Egyptian-American activist for his outspoken criticism of the regime’s poor human rights record in American public fora. The court accused Saad Eddin Ibrahim, of "tarnishing Egypt's image" abroad. The conviction referred primarily to writings he published in the foreign press; most notably among them an August 2007 op-ed in the Washington Post in which he criticized Egypt's human rights record and questioned the reasons behind US aid to Egypt. Full Story>>

Want to Fight Terrorism? Think Globally, Act Locally
 Globe and Mail (Toronto),
 August 4, 2008
Khalid Mustafa Medani

Militant Islam is under global scrutiny for clues to conditions that foster its rise, and to strategies for reversing that growth. But the key is not in Islamic doctrine, US foreign policy or formal ties to various nations, as many analysts have asserted. It lies at the community level, with clan and local leaders. Full Story>>

Iraq’s Kurds Have to Choose
 Globe and Mail (Toronto)
 July 30, 2008
Joost Hiltermann

Kurdish parties have become kingmakers in Baghdad , and they know it. As no federal government can work without them, they are pulling every available political lever to expand the territory and resources they control, trying to build the foundation of an independent Kurdish state. But even more than territory, they need security. If everyone acts quickly and wisely, that understanding could help resolve one of the Iraq war’s thorniest issues. Full Story>>

Exiting Iraq Is Easier Than They Say
 The Nation (web-only)
 July 16, 2008
Chris Toensing

The debate over the war in Iraq follows a yellowing script: The minute someone suggests that the US move to withdraw its troops, war supporters cry “Havoc!” True to form, when no less a figure than Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki stated he wants a timeline for a US pullout, John McCain summoned the specter of dire consequences. “I’ve always said we’ll come home with honor and with victory and not through a set timetable,” McCain said. In his major foreign policy speech on July 15, Barack Obama affirmed his support for a withdrawal timetable, adding that the US must “get out as carefully as we were careless getting in.” Obama’s position is the correct one, but he, like many other war critics, has done too little to counter the refrain that withdrawal is simply “cutting and running,” a recipe for disaster. Full Story>>
  Home | Contact/Intern | Background Info | Middle East Report | MER Online | Newspaper Op-Eds | Giving
Copyright © MERIP. All rights reserved.